Find out what other makers really think of your landing page. Free: you tell one of them what you think of theirs first.
What they send you is a crit: what they understood in the first few seconds, a 1–5 rating and an answer to the one question you asked. Writing one takes about two minutes, and each one you write earns you one on your own landing page or product, at any stage, from makers who buy tools like yours. No time to give? You can pay for them instead.
New accounts also get a few on the house, so you can put your page up on day one.
How it works
Give a crit
Open someone's page, say what you made of it in the first few seconds, rate it and answer the one question they asked. About two minutes.
Earn Echo
Every crit you send earns one Echo. That is the whole currency here: one Echo, one crit, no points to farm.
Get crits on your project
Put your own page up with the one question keeping you awake. Each crit costs one Echo and comes from a maker in the same spot as you.
What a crit looks like
Three parts, always in the same order. The first impression comes before the rating, so every score arrives with its reasons. The question is the one thing you wanted a stranger to tell you.
This one is a made-up example. Quietlist is not a real product.
I got that this is a waitlist tool, but not who it is for. The screenshot took a moment to load, so at first the page was just a button. Pricing was easy to find. I wanted to see one real list before signing up.
After signing up, would you know what to do first?
Honestly, no. The dashboard shows an empty state with three buttons and none of them says start here. Pick one and make it obvious.
Why it works
Not open-ended
Every crit has the same three parts, so you can line them up, spot the pattern and act, instead of decoding a wall of opinions.
From people in the same boat
Every crit is written by a maker who is waiting on crits of their own. They build tools, they buy tools, and they know how it feels to ship something and hear nothing.
Skip what you cannot judge
If a page is broken or not something you want to look at, skip it and move on. You only crit what you can actually speak to.
When time is the scarcer thing
Some weeks you have hours; some weeks you have a card. Buy Echo when it is the second kind. It spends exactly the same.
Pricing
About two minutes each. One Echo brings one crit back to your own project.
Pick how many you want, anywhere between the minimum and the maximum. Bought Echo works exactly like earned Echo.
FAQ
A short, structured read of a landing page or product, at any stage: what you understood in the first look, a rating on a fixed five-point scale, and an answer to the one question the maker asked.
Other members: makers who buy tools like yours, each waiting on crits of their own. Not a panel we recruit, and not people who already use your product — they read your page the way a stranger with a budget does.
About two minutes. You look at the page the way a stranger would, write down what you took from it, pick a rating and answer the question. The send button unlocks after a short minimum on the page — a real look, not a race.
One Echo for every crit you send. One Echo gets you one crit on your own project. Simple as that.
Yes. You pick the quantity within the minimum and the maximum, at the current price per Echo. Bought Echo spends exactly like earned Echo.
Skip it. If a page is broken, empty or not something you want to look at, pass and you get the next one.
Only to members while they are giving crits. It does not go on a public list anywhere.